DISCUSSION1 Please do not write about what the speech is about. evaluating delivery methods only. Instead relate to the book and how the speeches are delivered. CITE the BOOK with PAGE #. Minimum 150 words and reply to 2 peers. Compare and contrast delivery of these two videos. 1- Provide your own answer to this question. Cite one example to clarify your answer. 2-Explain the meaning of Plato’s cave. Could it be applied to today’s context? How? Give one or two examples

In evaluating the delivery methods of the two videos, it is important to examine how the speeches are delivered in relation to the book. Both videos present different approaches to delivering a speech, highlighting key aspects of effective communication.

In Video 1, the speaker utilizes a dynamic and expressive delivery style. She employs gestures and facial expressions to enhance her message and engage the audience. This can be seen in her use of hand movements to emphasize certain points and maintain the audience’s attention. In addition, the speaker maintains a conversational tone throughout, which creates a sense of intimacy and connection with the audience. This style of delivery is reminiscent of what Aristotle describes as the use of ethos, pathos, and logos in the book Rhetoric (Aristotle, Book I, Chapter 2, p. 2).

Video 2, on the other hand, displays a more formal and structured delivery approach. The speaker maintains a composed demeanor and employs logical arguments to deliver his message. He uses a clear and concise language, allowing the audience to easily follow his points. This delivery style is similar to what Aristotle refers to as the use of persuasion through logic in Rhetoric (Aristotle, Book II, Chapter 1, p. 8). By employing a structured and logical approach to delivery, the speaker effectively presents his ideas in a coherent manner.

Comparing the two videos, the main difference lies in their delivery styles. While Video 1 focuses on creating an emotional connection with the audience through expressive gestures and a conversational tone, Video 2 emphasizes logic and structure to deliver a clear and concise message. Both approaches have their merits, and their effectiveness can vary depending on the context and the audience.

In today’s context, the meaning of Plato’s cave can certainly be applied. The allegory of Plato’s cave, as discussed in his work The Republic (Plato, Book VII, 514a), represents the idea that most people live in a state of ignorance and are only aware of a distorted reality. In this allegory, prisoners are chained inside a cave and are only able to perceive shadows cast on the walls by objects passing in front of a fire behind them. These prisoners mistake the shadows for reality because they have never experienced anything else.

This notion of being trapped in an illusory understanding of reality is still relevant today. In our contemporary society, we are bombarded with information from various sources, such as social media, news outlets, and advertisements. These sources can shape our understanding of the world, often presenting a skewed or distorted view. Just like the prisoners in Plato’s cave, we may remain unaware of the true nature of things and accept the presented reality as truth.

One example of how the allegory of Plato’s cave can be applied to today’s context is through the spread of misinformation and fake news. In the digital age, it has become increasingly difficult to discern between reliable and unreliable sources of information. People may unknowingly remain trapped in the cave of misinformation, accepting false narratives without questioning their validity. This can have serious consequences, as it impacts our understanding of the world and the decisions we make based on that understanding.

Another example is the power of social conditioning and societal norms. Often, we are influenced by the values, beliefs, and expectations of the society we belong to. Just as the prisoners in Plato’s cave are shaped by their confined environment, we may be shaped by the norms and expectations of our own societies. This can limit our perspectives and hinder our ability to think critically and independently.

In conclusion, the delivery methods utilized in the two videos highlight different approaches to effective communication. Video 1 emphasizes emotional connection and expressiveness, while Video 2 focuses on logic and structure. Evaluating these videos in relation to the book, we can draw comparisons and understand how the concept of Plato’s cave can still be applied to today’s context.